Lo runs into Curtis, a guy she dated last summer but dumped him because he wasn't cute enough. Later it is revealed that he is going out with Fin. Lo introduces Reef as her boyfriend to make Curtis jealous (even though Reef and she aren't dating; Lo later bribes Reef into it by saying she'll get him his own mini-fridge), but Curtis proposes that he and Fin, along with Lo and Reef go on a double date.

He creates a surfing simulator video game so he can find more time to surf while still teaching his students, but his scheme backfires when the game becomes popular and it leads to him getting fired by Bummer.

Fin and Reef compete to see who will become special surf advisor to a hot young Hollywood star. But their plans go awry when the hunk chooses Broseph as his advisor and proceeds to steal Broseph's identity one step at at time.

Reef and Broseph smell a way to make money based on the town's most popular food stuff: Beaver Tails. Meanwhile, Lo thinks she is starting to look pale like Emma, so she buys a tanning product that makes her smell like bacon and has to be reapplied every 20 minutes or she turns orange.

When Lo sees Ty cleaning up after a littering surfer over Kelly's objections, she helps Emma by setting her up with Ty for beach clean-up duty, prompting a jealous Kelly to interfere. Meanwhile, Reef, Fin, Broseph and Johnny try to find a way to skip work and catch some waves.

Lo and Reef struggle to keep their new romantic relationship a secret from their friends amid several close calls. Johnny sets up a spy camera to see what the waves are like. But, later shows Lo and Reef making out, causing it to become a local television show That's So Reef and Lo.

On a stormy night, Reef gets freaked out when he sees three mysterious figures outside the staff house and suspects that they are vampires.

The groms believe that Broseph has become psychic and developed the ability to predict the location and size of waves, not knowing that one of Mr. Grizzle's hearing aids has become lodged in Broseph's afro. Meanwhile, Reef is out-surfed by two of his students – little boys.

Fin gets annoyed with Reef's new relationship with Lo and tries to compete against her to see who Reef really likes the most. Meanwhile, Bummer wants Emma and Broseph to get rid of the mother turtle making babies on the beach, but causes trouble when all the baby turtles are missing in the hotel.

Meanwhile, Emma tries on a wetsiut belonging to a famous guest who is staying at the hotel, but gets stuck and can't take it off.

Broseph eats a sandwich that makes him sick. Johnny makes lots of bets.

After a series of unfortunate mishaps, the groms finally get fed up with their living conditions in the old staff house and declare a strike.